Becoming a parent to a newborn is an incredible experience. But the sleepless nights that often come with it can quickly become overwhelming. If your baby wakes frequently at night, you may start wondering whether sleep training is the solution for your family.

In this article, we explain what sleep training is, why many parents and professionals advise caution, and explore gentler alternatives to sleep training that support your baby’s emotional needs and natural sleep development.

Why Is Sleep So Important for Your Baby?

Before discussing sleep training, it’s essential to understand why quality sleep is critical for babies.

Sleep is not a luxury for infants – it is a biological necessity. Babies spend a large part of their early life sleeping, and this sleep plays a key role in both physical and mental development. During deep sleep, the body releases growth hormones that support healthy growth, brain development, and immune function.

When babies do not get enough restorative sleep, it can potentially impact their development and overall wellbeing.

The Effects of Sleep Deprivation

Lack of sleep can affect babies in several ways. Overtired infants may become more irritable, harder to soothe, and have difficulty regulating emotions. Over time, chronic sleep deprivation may also influence cognitive development and learning.

Sleep challenges don’t just affect babies – parents often experience increased stress, exhaustion, and strain on relationships due to ongoing sleep disruption.

What Is Sleep Training?

Sleep training refers to methods designed to teach babies to fall asleep and stay asleep independently, without parental assistance.

Common sleep training methods include:

  • Cry It Out (CIO)

  • Controlled Crying

  • The Ferber Method

  • Graduated Extinction

These approaches typically involve placing the baby in bed awake and allowing them to cry for set periods before offering comfort. Over time, the intervals between parental check-ins are increased, with the goal that the baby learns to self-soothe and fall asleep alone.

Why Is Sleep Training Often Discouraged?

While sleep training may work for some families, it is frequently discouraged due to several concerns:

Emotional stress

Critics argue that allowing a baby to cry without immediate comfort may cause emotional distress, fear, or anxiety, especially in very young infants.

Impact on attachment

Some professionals worry that sleep training may interfere with secure attachment, as babies rely on caregivers to respond consistently to their needs, particularly at night.

Not effective for all babies

Sleep training does not work for every child. Some babies continue to wake frequently despite training, which can lead to frustration for parents.

Individual needs matter

Every baby is unique. Some infants need more comfort, reassurance, and physical closeness than others – especially during developmental leaps or periods of separation anxiety.

Gentle Alternatives to Sleep Training

The good news is that sleep training is not the only way to improve your baby’s sleep. There are gentler, responsive approaches that support both sleep and emotional wellbeing.

1. Create a Calm Sleep Environment

A soothing sleep environment can make a big difference:

  • Temperature: Aim for a comfortable room temperature (around 20–22°C / 68–72°F).

  • Darkness: Use blackout curtains to reduce light exposure.

  • White noise: Soft, consistent background noise can help mask household sounds.

  • Safe bedding: Use a firm mattress and avoid loose items in the crib.

2. Establish a Consistent Bedtime Routine

Babies thrive on predictability. A calming bedtime routine helps signal that sleep is approaching.

A bedtime routine may include:

  • A warm bath

  • Gentle massage

  • A bedtime story or song

  • Quiet cuddles

Consistency is key. Repeating the same routine every night helps your baby associate these activities with sleep.

3. Consider Co-Sleeping or Room-Sharing

For some families, co-sleeping or room-sharing can lead to more restful nights. Sleeping close to your baby can make nighttime feeding and comforting easier and may reduce night waking.

If you choose to co-sleep, safety is essential:

  • Use a firm, flat mattress

  • Avoid soft bedding, pillows, or heavy blankets near the baby

  • Never co-sleep if you are under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or sedating medication

  • Ensure your baby has their own safe sleep space

Room-sharing (baby sleeping in their own cot in the same room) can also provide closeness without sharing a bed.

In Summary

Sleep training aims to teach babies to sleep independently, often by limiting parental comfort during night wakings. While it may work for some families, it is widely debated due to concerns about emotional stress and attachment.

Fortunately, there are gentle, responsive alternatives. Creating a calm sleep environment, maintaining a consistent bedtime routine, and considering co-sleeping or room-sharing can all support better sleep – without leaving your baby to cry alone.

Every baby is different. Trust your instincts, respond to your baby’s needs, and remember that sleep challenges are often temporary.

More stories

Why Babies May Sleep Better in Structured Sleepwear: A Simple Parent Guide

Discover how structured sleepwear can enhance your baby's nighttime rest. This guide explains why babies may sleep better in structured sleepwear, offering security, stable temperatures, and a calming bedtime routine. Learn how gentle structure helps minimize movements during sleep and supports a peaceful environment.

Children’s Sleep Needs: A Guide for New Parents

Understanding your baby’s sleep needs doesn’t have to be overwhelming. This guide explains how baby sleep cycles work, how much sleep babies need at different ages, and practical ways to support healthy, calm sleep habits from newborn to toddler.